The best car insurance companies have a few things in common: They have straightforward shopping experiences, take good care of policyholders after a crash and treat their customers with respect and courtesy. That means only insurers with high customer satisfaction scores and relatively few complaints to insurance commissioners make it to the top of our list of the best auto insurance companies.

Nationwide’s coverage selection is more or less on par with companies like Progressive, Allstate, and GEICO. It includes all the core coverage options — from liability to uninsured motorist — as well as some add-ons that may be hard to find elsewhere, like GAP insurance, rideshare coverage, and accident forgiveness. Like other top companies, Nationwide also offers plenty of discounts. Customers can save by bundling home and auto insurance, installing safety devices on their car, taking a defensive driving course, staying accident free, and more.
TheGeneralAutoQuotes.com offers insurance products and services from The General® and its affiliated insurance companies (Permanent General Assurance Corporation, Permanent General Assurance Corporation of Ohio and The General Automobile Insurance Company, Inc.) through Clear Link Insurance Agency, LLC in the following states: (AL – 662369), (AR – 416243), (AZ – 10394470, (CA – 0i22561), (CO – 419732), (CT – 2424421), (DC – 3041371), (DE – 1326873), (FL – L088857), (GA – 172259), (IA – 1002207278), (ID – 439793), (IL – 100640719), (IN – 869503), (KS – 461715304), (KY – DOI-805173), (LA – 582580), (MA – 1930638), (MD – 2112735), (ME – AGN213175), (MI – 100259), (MN – 40325516), (MO – 8287507), (MS – 15021382), (MT – AP770689), (NC -1000341544), (ND – 2000115021), (NE – 100196040), (NH – 2268499), (NJ – 1515723), (NV – 947846), (NV – 876621), (OH – 985962), (OK – 100151491), (OR – 100213920), (PA – 666488), (SC – 193263), (SD – 10016345), (TN – 2238715), (TX – 1821698), (UT – 436588), (VA – 133866), (VT – 873256), (WA – 828648), (WI – 2609707), (WV – 100149165), (WY – 238959).
Claims and price satisfaction: We looked at J.D. Power’s 2018 Auto Claims Satisfaction Reports, Insure.com’s Best Car Insurance Companies for 2018, and Consumer Reports’ 2017 Car Insurance Ratings to get a bird’s-eye view of the industry across the nation. We also conducted a survey of 100 insured drivers who had filed a claim within the past 12 months.

The Zebra didn’t allow me to customize coverage preferences, forcing me to choose one of four pre-assembled packages. It also didn’t list which companies allowed which discounts, making their earlier list of pre-qualified discounts less useful. On the right side of the page, the site provided an “Insurability Score” listing the factors that insurance companies use to set rates and grading the information I’d provided during the quoting process, which could help drivers looking to improve their rates in the future.
Auto-Owners Insurance Group is another powerful contender for customer ratings. In terms of claims satisfaction, Consumer Reports gives Auto-Owners a 93 (eighth place out of 27 companies rated), and J.D. Power dubs the company “better than most.” It also took first place for customer satisfaction in J.D. Power’s survey of the North Central region. To top it off, Auto-Owners matches the coverage selection at other top companies. Add-ons like roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, GAP insurance, new car replacement, and accident forgiveness can help to round out your policy.
Product highlights: American Family developed the Dreams Restored Program (DRP) for its auto insurance customers. If a policyholder uses a DRP-certified repair shop after filing a claim, the repairs have a lifetime warranty and the bill goes to American Family rather than to the customer. Some perks offered by American Family include gap coverage and rideshare insurance in select states.
In addition, while The General makes it easy to get a quote and streamlines the process of obtaining coverage, many drivers report a complicated claims process that often results in unsatisfactory payouts. This also holds true for repairs — customers have noted that The General often does its best to keep from paying for coverage it promised. If you’re at the end of the road when it comes to insurance options, The General may be able to provide you with a policy, but we wouldn’t recommend it for most drivers.
×